Hiring an SEO agency in the UK can involve comparing proposals that sound similar but contain very different amounts of work. One may include changes to your website; another may provide recommendations for your developer. Both might call the service “technical SEO”. The useful comparison starts beneath those labels.
This guide gives you a practical way to assess services, costs and questions before you commit. It is written for business owners commissioning support, rather than as a ranking of agencies. You can also review Alchemist Media’s current SEO service alongside your own requirements.
What should an SEO agency actually do?
A useful proposal connects a problem with a specific action. “Improve visibility” is an objective; reviewing which service pages can be found, correcting an indexing problem or rewriting a confusing page title is work. Ask the agency to explain the connection in language your team can use.
Technical work concerns how the site functions and how search engines access and understand it. Content work concerns what customers need to know and whether the relevant pages answer those questions. Google’s SEO Starter Guide provides a useful background to search-friendly structure and helpful content. You do not need to become a specialist to ask which part of your site a recommendation will change.
Other services may include keyword research, internal linking, outreach and reporting. Ask for examples of the deliverable in each category. A content brief is an outline for a writer, not necessarily a completed article. An outreach activity is not the same thing as a published mention. Keep these distinctions visible in the quote.
Write a short brief before comparing proposals
Begin with what your business wants more of: enquiries for a particular service, purchases from a defined product range or discovery in an area you actually serve. List the pages and customer actions associated with that objective. Avoid asking an agency to increase every metric across the whole website at once.
Give each shortlisted agency the same starting information:
- The services or products you want to prioritise, and where you sell them.
- The website platform and the person who can approve and implement changes.
- Any planned redesign, migration or change of business focus.
- Existing reporting access and any gaps in enquiry or sales tracking.
- Your available budget and the time your team can contribute.
Include constraints as well as ambitions. If your developer can only release changes once a month, a proposal dependent on weekly development needs discussion. If you cannot supply specialist product knowledge, establish who will check content accuracy. These details influence whether a sensible recommendation becomes a completed improvement.
Compare scope, ownership and evidence
Turn each proposal into the same simple worksheet. This makes it easier to compare a low-cost package with a broader service without assuming that either is the better fit. Ask the agency to fill gaps before you sign.
| Proposed work | Scope to specify | Owner to name | Evidence to request |
|---|---|---|---|
| Technical review | Pages or templates examined and issues prioritised | Auditor and person implementing fixes | Issue list, agreed priorities and completed-change checks |
| Page improvements | Named pages and the changes included | Writer, reviewer and publisher | Approved copy and links to updated pages |
| Content planning | Briefs, finished writing or both | Subject expert and content producer | Accepted brief or publication-ready draft |
| Reporting | Measures, reporting period and comparison basis | Analyst and business contact | Results, limitations and next actions |
For example, “optimise service pages” becomes more useful when the proposal names the pages, identifies who approves the wording and explains how the live changes will be checked. That is an example of a clearer scope, not a prediction of rankings or enquiries.
Agree what happens when the initial review reveals more work than the monthly allowance covers. You might prioritise a smaller set of pages, buy separate development time or defer a lower-priority task. The important point is to decide consciously, with the additional cost and responsibility recorded.

Understand the monthly price and what sits outside it
Use a quoted price as the starting point for a scope conversation. Ask whether it includes implementation, completed writing, reporting meetings and any specialist tools you will need to retain. Confirm VAT treatment, setup charges, extra work and the total payable before ordering. Do not assume that the headline fee settles all of those questions.
As checked on 21 November 2026, Alchemist Media lists SEO Starter at £299 per month for five target keywords and SEO Standard at £799 per month for 20 target keywords. These are examples of our published packages, not UK market averages or an estimate of the right budget for every business. Check the live offer and confirm your specific requirements with the team.
The service page lists research, technical work, on-page optimisation, content briefs, outreach and monthly reporting. A keyword allowance describes one part of that package. It does not, by itself, tell you how many substantial pages will be written, how extensive a development change will be or which external costs apply. Ask for those boundaries in writing.
Compare the total workload on both sides. A cheaper proposal may be appropriate when your team can implement recommendations. If you need the agency to handle implementation and content production, price that complete requirement rather than comparing fees for different services.
Ask questions that reveal how the agency works
Google’s guide to hiring an SEO suggests asking about previous work, relevant experience and communication. It also describes using read-only Search Console access for a prospective audit and warns against promises of first place. Those are helpful starting checks; an agency still needs to explain how its proposed work fits your business.
- What would you investigate first, and why? Look for reasoning tied to your site rather than an identical task list for every client.
- Who will do and approve the work? Establish your regular contact, specialist support and your own review responsibilities.
- What does the example result actually demonstrate? Ask about the period, starting position and work performed. A screenshot alone leaves considerable context unknown.
- Which changes need separate approval or payment? Include development, new content and third-party services.
- How will you explain disappointing results? Ask how the team separates completed work, measurement limitations and its next hypothesis.
- What will we retain if the relationship ends? Agree access, files, reporting history and handover arrangements.
For outreach, ask about the proposed method and how opportunities are reviewed. For case studies, ask for relevant context rather than access to another customer’s confidential data. You are looking for a credible account of decisions and work, not a promise that another business’s outcome will repeat.
Use the first 90 days as a review structure
A first-quarter plan can make responsibilities clearer, but it should not be treated as a deadline for a particular search result. The following is an illustrative review structure to adapt with the agency.
At the start: agree access, record the starting position, inspect priority pages and select the first tasks. Confirm what your own team must supply. If tracking is incomplete, document the gap before comparing results.
At the first delivery review: inspect the changes that have actually gone live. Compare them with the agreed scope. Resolve delayed approvals or development dependencies, and check whether the original priorities still make sense.
At the quarter review: assess completed work alongside the available search and business evidence. Identify what remains uncertain and agree the next priorities. A missed delivery commitment and a completed change with an uncertain search impact are different problems; discuss them separately.
Read reports without confusing visibility with revenue
Google Search Console’s Performance report includes impressions, clicks, click-through rate and average position. These describe aspects of search visibility and interaction, not completed sales. Its filters let you examine pages, queries, countries, devices and periods, which can help make a comparison more meaningful.
Ask the agency to state the dates and filters used. A change across the whole site may conceal a different pattern on your priority service pages. Average position also needs context: it is not a fixed place that every potential customer sees for a search.
Keep a separate business view. Where your measurement supports it, review relevant enquiries, purchases and enquiry quality. Mark missing or uncertain attribution plainly. An increase in forms submitted may include irrelevant enquiries; it should not automatically be described as an increase in valuable leads.
A useful monthly discussion ends with a decision: continue a promising activity, investigate a discrepancy, repair a measurement gap or change the priorities. Reports earn their place by informing that decision, not by being long.

Frequently asked questions
Should I choose an SEO agency or a freelancer?
Compare the people and work available for your specific brief. A freelancer may suit a focused requirement; an agency may offer several disciplines. Neither structure proves quality. Confirm capacity, specialist coverage, communication and who handles implementation in either case.
Is a larger keyword package always better?
No. Start with the relevant services, locations and pages you can realistically support. A larger allowance is useful only when the broader scope fits your business and the work needed. Ask how closely related queries are grouped and how priorities will be chosen.
Can I assess SEO without understanding every technical term?
Yes. Ask what problem the task addresses, what will change, who will change it and what evidence will show it was completed. You can request a plain-English explanation without pretending that every search outcome is predictable.
What should I send when asking for a proposal?
Send your website address, priority services or products, target areas, objective and practical constraints. Explain who maintains the site and whether you need writing or implementation support. Share account access through an agreed secure process, rather than putting passwords in an enquiry.
Discuss the scope before choosing a package
Review our SEO service and current package structure, then contact Alchemist Media with your website and priorities. Ask the team to confirm the work, implementation responsibilities and total cost for your situation. A clear brief makes that conversation more useful than choosing on keyword count alone.
Recent Comments